February 25, 2009

Q&A: Real Party of Interest

Q. I had been making payments for more than a year to Company X and fell behind on my mortgage payments by a couple of months. Today I got what looks like a foreclosure notice from a company I have never heard of before. The amount they say I owe is wrong and they are claiming that I have not made payments for the past 8 months. I don’t want to lose my home over some mistake but I can’t afford an attorney. Is there some way that I can figure out how to keep my home on my own?

A. There is a strong possibility that you may be able to block the foreclosure long enough to figure out what is going on. Your first step is to file an “answer” (see here) to all the correct parties.

Let’s cover some basics about the “real party of interest.” The real party of interest is the only entity or individual who can be the plaintiff in a lawsuit. Concerning your mortgage or deed of trust, the real party must either have purchased or otherwise have acquired legal ownership of the collateral in order to sue you as a plaintiff for non-payment of the debt. There is also a provision for a servicer who has been granted servicing rights “with assigns” to be the named plaintiff as well, since such a arrangement grants all rights to the holder as though they were the rightful owner. “Servicing rights only” does NOT grant one the power to sue for payment as a plaintiff in a foreclosure action.

In all cases, the named plaintiff should be able to provide documentation that they have the legal right to pursue you for payment. Send a qualified written request and demand that they provide such documentation. The documentation you need is a copy of the transfer of your note/deed of trust. Or proof that a transfer of servicing rights “with assigns” was made prior to the filing of the foreclosure. With so many lenders making transfers of files all the time, they have gotten really sloppy about these little details. Many times servicers are identified as plaintiffs in a foreclosure action when they have no legal right to do so. Challenge the validity of the action, not the truthfulness of your default. Additionally, dispute the amount declared to be in default and request documentation of all funds paid by you on the account.

Essentially I am saying that many foreclosures are processed and completed, folks lose their homes when the lawsuit was filed by someone who was not, in fact, the “real party of interest.” A consumer borrowed money from Bank X, who transferred the loan to Bank Y, who was then bought by Bank Z. Bank Z owned Bank Y, but your note is still held by Bank Y. Bank Z cannot legally be the plaintiff until there is a transfer of your SPECIFIC note to Bank Z.

It’s a simple concept once you think about it. Use an attorney if you don’t feel competent doing it yourself; but I think you could handle this yourself once you fully understand.


Copyright © 2009, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All rights Reserved. "Answer Book in a Foreclosure Climate" by Mildred Wilkins, available in 2009 from www.DovePublishingHouse.com.

(Please e-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments, or concerns you might have. We appreciate all feedback, comments, and especially your questions. Don't be shy!)

No comments:

Post a Comment