Showing posts sorted by date for query closing agent. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query closing agent. Sort by relevance Show all posts
March 10, 2010
Q&A: Listing agent to help me buy
Q. Last week while visiting open houses, I found a house which I really, really like and want to purchase. The listing agent has been very helpful and since I don’t have an agent, she is encouraging me to go ahead and let her help me with the purchase before someone else gets it. Is it a good idea to let the listing agent represent me as well?
A. Agency is the relationship you establish when you select or engage someone to represent you. It is a legal arrangement where you become the principal and they, as your agent has a responsibility to protect your interests in helping you complete a transaction. It is implicit in this agreement that they have a fiduciary responsibility to put your interests first.
Dual agency
The situation you are asking about is commonly called dual agency, where one party represents both people. It is entirely legal, but can become complicated. The agent must disclose to both clients the existence of the other client (get you to sign a paper which says you understand and are comfortable with this arrangement). The legal requirement addresses the issue of appropriate disclosure; it does not address the issue of human nature. Human nature is such that most of us are going to choose between two individuals one of them whom we like a little better or for some reason feel a little closer to and work harder to get what they want out of a situation. In addition, in a house purchase, the listing agent has a relationship FIRST with the sellers. Even if there is an agreement to treat all parties fairly, if there is a major inspection issue (for instance) it is likely to be harder for the agent to press the people who listed with her to spend the necessary money when they already have an accepted price. On the other hand, if you had selected a buyer’s agent whose only responsibility is to represent you, then your agent can fight aggressively for having the repair done since they have NO connection to nor consideration for the seller.
Limited or dual agency is very popular with many agents who contend there does not have to be a conflict and they can handle any conflict which arises.
I disagree and believe that while dual agency may be legal, it is fraught with the opportunity for a buyer to receive less than full representation. The major fringe benefit for agents is that dual agency comes with dual paychecks. When I sold real estate, I declined dual agency unless it was an inter-family transaction where they simply needed a competent agent to process the transaction but they were already in agreement about the details.
I will never forget one transaction where I had the listing and my client did NOT understand why I did not want to represent a buyer who wanted her property. I explained dual agency and the problem which that MIGHT create. I told her I wanted her house to sell but I did not want to represent the buyer.
She took that to mean I didn’t think much of her house (which was a reflection of her lack of self esteem and lack of understanding of agency as I had explained it to her). Her house appeared to be in excellent condition, very well kept, neat, clean. Roughly a $65,000 starter home in Indianapolis. I would not have listed it had I not felt comfortable with its presentation and my ability to sell it. We get the house under contract with a young woman who had wanted me to represent her as well since she did not have an agent when she first looked at the property during an open house. I had insisted she had to go find another REALTOR since I would only represent the listing side.
Her inspection uncovered a major leak in the attic which required a full roof replacement for FHA financing. Neither my seller nor I had any idea there was a problem with the roof since there had not yet been a leak inside the house, but here we are with an accepted offer, scheduled to close in two weeks. She is looking at an outlay of more than $4,000 to put on a new roof which would eat up almost every penny which she expected to get from the proceeds AND she didn’t have the funds to do it in advance. We tried to negotiate to get the buyer to increase her purchase price, to no avail. My seller was unwilling to move forward to closing at the agreed price AND shell out the funds for the roof. We did not close because she could not (chose not) to correct the problem. I supported her position. I felt she had a legitimate position. She somehow felt that if I had represented the buyer I could have made her accept the house without the roof replacement and that I had cost her the sale. She did NOT relist with me.
I am sharing that I refused to participate in dual agency and still lost the transaction and some agents reading this will say I should have represented both of them. I am more convinced than I was before that transaction began that the worse possible situation for me would have been representing both of these women—essentially AGAINST each other—over a $4,000 roof issue.
In real life, too often agents do press one party to go ahead when they run in a scenario similar to the one above. When they do so, they fail to pass the test of integrity and do a disservice to the real estate industry and the clients whom they profess to represent. The general public has significantly less regard for all real estate salespeople, including REALTORS, than they did 10-12 years ago. We have lost their respect as a profession because of the multitude of agents who do not adhere to the standards which had placed us in such high regards just a mere 20 years ago.
Agents: Will you be part of the move toward professionalism? Integrity? Respect?
Consumers: Will you become better educated about what you should expect from your agent and then demand that they provide a level of service which you are comfortable with?
You’re paying for it, you deserve no less!
Copyright © 2009, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
January 2, 2010
Q&A: Offer Doesn't Cover Loan
Q: A common question over the past year has been: “What happens if I am trying to sell my house and I am not able to get a new buyer who will pay as much as my outstanding loan?” “What are my options then?”
A: The questions you raise are faced by many borrowers across the country and the answers to your questions vary somewhat depending on several factors:
a. Your circumstances, including your reason for default
b. Your guarantor, meaning who ultimately is holding the loan and stands to lose the amount NOT being offered by the new buyer
c. Your resources, ie. Money in savings, retirement account, etc.
d. Current restrictions or requirements from external forces such as the TREASURY
Ordinarily, to sell your home, you need to get an offer which will cover all the costs associated with the transfer AND cover the full amount due to the lender to pay off your mortgage in full. In today’s climate frequently the value of the home has fallen and that is not possible, creating what is now commonly called a ‘short sale’. The lender may require one of more of the following options:
1. You sign an unsecured note for the difference (or an amount you negotiate which is less than the difference but will satisfy the guarantor).
2. You bring a check to closing for the difference between the offer and the amount owed.
3. Someone other than you (the real estate agent, the purchaser) pay the difference or a negotiated, compromised amount in order to allow the closing to move forward
HOW do you handle a potential sale when you are not likely to get all that you owe from a new buyer?
Select a REALTOR® who is experienced in handling short sales in your area and work closely with them in providing everything your lender/servicer is requesting in order to get them to accept an amount which is consistent with the current value of the home.
IF you cannot negotiate a compromise for less than the full amount owed: THEN foreclosure is frequently the outcome.
Best of luck with your attempt to move your home in today’s market. With market savvy and determination, it can be done!
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
December 14, 2009
...From the Desk of..."Are You Ready to Intervene?"
Twenty Questions for Today’s Real Estate Professional
I was recently asked by the Charleston Trident Board of REALTORS® to differentiate the (FIS) Foreclosure Intervention Specialist certification from other short sale certification programs. Please know that the Board has offered both the (SFR) (Short Sales and Foreclosure Certification) and the (LMC) (Loan Modification Certification) certifications which are excellent programs.
Both have been widely attended in Charleston and I strongly encourage you to sign up for one or both at the next opportunity. Every single licensee should avail themselves of a basic short sale class so they have a rudimentary understanding of this ‘new’ transaction which is dominating the market in many parts of the country.
(FIS) will be offered for the first time in South Carolina beginning March 2010, courtesy of a FPR (Foreclosure Prevention and Response) grant from NAR. I think the operative word of distinction is ‘basic’ as compared to ’comprehensive’. This 30 hour program is designed for the agent who has decided to commit to getting an in-depth understanding of the various facets of handling these intricate transactions—the relationship connection, the Law, the Ethics, property valuation, the process, the negotiating, getting to the closing table, the downside, the resources needed, community partnerships, the self-study to continue to grow and much, much more.
Why offer (FIS)? Because hundreds of students who had taken either the 4 or 8 hour basic short sale training classes offered by Home Ownership Matters beginning in 2003 demanded more. More time, more expansive, more details. The course evolved and in 2005, the (FIS) certification was introduced in Ohio. Since then (FIS) has been approved for CE credit in six (6) states and there are graduates from twelve (12) states. States approved for CE include: Ohio, Indiana, Kansas, Nebraska, Colorado and Oklahoma.
30 hours, 700+ pages of material.
Tried and true methodology coupled with sound philosophy
from a former Fannie Mae Broker-Specialist
Updated regularly and state specific (Law section)
I decided the easiest way to say what you’ll learn is to pose the questions which will be addressed.
Are you ready to intervene?
1. Do you know how to distinguish a ’frozen customer’ from a potential short sale client? Do you currently use an intake form to determine who is a viable candidate for this type transaction and who is just not prepared for the commitment? Can you screen OUT the 60% of folks whom you should not list as short sales?
2. Are you prepared to analyze/distinguish the many HATS which may be required to help someone who is in default: the social worker, medical counselor, marriage counselor, human resources helper, spiritual advisor, budget counselor, salesperson extraordinaire, valuation expert, etc.
Are you real clear on what role you can and/or should play? Are you connected to/familiar with the community resources to address those needs which are outside of your scope of expertise? Do you currently utilize a referral form for this purpose? Can you see the potential for a fair housing complaint (or other complaint) without some standardized referral policy/form?
3. Do you know how to ‘handle’ the law while avoiding the ‘practice of law’? Do you clearly understand that it is necessary to understand some components of the law (and be able to explain them to your client) as part of a short sale attempt or an REO purchase?
4. Do you understand the impact of the seller filing bankruptcy on a potential short sale? The increased likelihood of a deed-in-lieu? Do you currently discuss this at the onset with your customer since it could/should end your relationship if they file later?
5. Are you familiar with the new Treasury guidelines for short sale—other than the fact that the commission cannot be reduced below 6%? Have you studied the guidelines? Do you understand them?
6. Are you familiar with the foreclosure law in your state? Is it a judicial or non-judicial process? What difference does it make? The guidelines for service on a defaulted borrower? Familiar with what the customary forms are and what they look like? Are you aware that violation of state foreclosure law can work in a borrower’s favor to gain extra time which could be used to facilitate a short sale? Or a reverse mortgage?
7. Do you have the expertise to accurately determine the value of a property in today’s declining market? Are you familiar with the professional BPO which is used as the industry standard (fanniemaebpo.com)? Could you complete one and do you understand why it can be much more accurate than the more commonly used CMA or market analysis? Are you clear on why accurate property valuation, from the beginning, plays such a critical role in the success or failure of your short sale effort?
8. Do you feel you clearly understand the unique protocol for short sales, not to be confused with REO and traditional sales? Who signs what? When? Presentation of offers? To whom?
9. Have you figured out what to disclose? To whom? And when?
Are the guidelines set by your Broker consistent with both Federal and state requirements/prohibitions on disclosure? Are you clear on the Who? What? When? HOW?
10. Are you familiar with your Board and Broker’s position on:
a. Disclosure—Who? When? How?
b. Commission—Who? What? When? How?
c. Signing of offers/amendments/price reductions—Who? When?
d. Presentation of offers—To whom? When? Signatures? Why?
e. Multiple offers—that is a whole other 20 questions
11. Does your brokerage utilize a set of disclosure forms which have been customized for the use with short sale scenarios? Are you familiar with them? Do you understand the protection that you may gain from covering the special risks associated with short sale transactions? Are you interested?
12. Do you understand the tax implications for a borrower who has completed a short sale? Please don’t tell me that you thought they were off scot free because the short sale was approved. (They are not) Do you have a referral to a tax accountant?
13. Have you read your state’s Seller Disclosure Law? Have you studied the state disclosure form? Does it include a reference to “threatened or pending litigation“? Or perhaps “notices from any Government or quasi-governmental agency”? Any “challenge to the title”? Are you clear on why any/all of these could forestall a short sale approval and therefore need to be disclosed?
14. Do you have clarity on the impact of a foreclosure on your customer’s ability to purchase down the road? Was that part of your discussion about the reason to consider a short sale in the first place? Have you discussed operating ‘in good faith’ as vital to the ability to keep the house on the market?
15. Is there a 2nd (or 3rd) mortgage? Are there other potential liens against the home (home owners’ association, taxes, personal judgment) which must be dealt with? Got a plan for how you are going to handle those? Do you know where to start?
16. Do you clearly understand the role of the Guarantor and/or the investor in determining whether or not a specific short sale can be approved? For that matter, do you know that the Servicer is merely a go-between hired to facilitate the administration of the loan but is NOT a decision maker? Who is? How can you find them? What are THEIR guidelines? Are they the same from Guarantor to Guarantor? Available in public records?
17. Are you familiar with the Qualified Written Request—backed by Federal Law (RESPA, no less) and the impact it can have as a ‘tool’ in delaying the foreclosure process if well-prepared? Used effectively and in a timely manner, you can gain valuable time to complete the short sale. We’ll cover that.
18. Has your firm/Broker created a “hold harmless” document which covers the scenarios which you cannot be responsible for with the clear understanding from your client that you will have no liability? Since the risk of lawsuit is pretty high with this new type of transaction, getting some understanding of what should be included and why should be paramount, I would think.
19. Have you identified as an agent/brokerage/Broker those scenarios which will require you to end the relationship? Have you established a policy concerning the need for a unilateral (not mutual) release? Under what circumstances, with what notice?
Certainly advance disclosure would be required: I would recommend at the inception of the agency relationship. We cover in detail during (FIS) training what I call the “Divorce Decree”. What happens if the client abandons? Files Bk? Enters into a deed-in-lieu? Refuses showings? Fails to cooperate in other ways? Policies should drive practices and both help to minimize liability.
Proper training and thorough understanding on each of these issues is paramount in order for you to be both effective at processing a short sale from beginning to end AND avoid the various opportunities to get yourself or your client into serious trouble along the way.
Short sales are the new reality for many markets around the country. They have become a major part of the market (along with REO’s) and becoming intimately familiar with how to process them successfully is paramount for any agent who wishes to thrive in today’s market.
If you do not already have clarity on ALL the issues which have been addressed in this article, then you are a prime candidate for the (FIS) certification program. Each of these will be explored and addressed during this 30 hour training program. You will leave with clarity on every single point covered here and will have the expertise to feel confident that you are representing your client with strong tools which have prepared you to be successful in getting the result you hope for and they deserve. YOUR knowledge base is a key component of your professionalism. Your success as a REALTOR® is tied directly to the caliber of your information.
Don’t miss an opportunity to learn, explore and interact with one of leading instructors on this timely topic. Her experience actually doing short sales, her time with Fannie Mae as a Broker-Specialist and expansive training (HUD, Fannie Mae, NeighborWorks, Legal Services, and National Consumer Law Center) can be invaluable to you.
Sign up today! Coming soon to a classroom near you!
Final Question
Is there someone in your office to whom you can refer a customer who needs short sale help? Within your firm? Maybe you can/should become that ‘Referral agent’ if you do not have the expertise today.
Are you Ready to Intervene????
*(FIS) is a registered trademark of Home Ownership Matters, LLC.
Other Foreclosure Resources
3. www.HomeOwnershipMatters.com — Calendar and Foreclosure/Loss Mitigation sections
4. www.nti.org — NeighborWorks America — Training Institute
5. www.consumerlaw.org — National Consumer Law Center
Mildred Wilkins
President of Home Ownership Matters
Author of “Your Real Estate Advisor”
available at: www.DovePublishingHouse.com
Toll-free 1 (866) 507-5105
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
October 16, 2009
From the Desk Of..."Nothing from Nothing"
Nothing from Nothing Leaves Nothing
“And that ain’t nothing, believe you me” is a refrain of a popular song from my youth. Who knew they were talking about real estate commissions? In today’s tight market it behooves you to start with the end in mind. Literally. It would seem obvious that licensees would always do that since they’re self-employed, paid only via commissions. Unfortunately, keen observation signals that far too often REALTORS® focus on the accumulation of listings without focusing on the realistic possibility of a completed closing. They bought into the myth that whoever has the most listings is the winner of the trophy and therefore is most productive.
Something is Wrong With This Picture . . .
Can you imagine an agent who regularly carries an inventory of 25+ listings (average price $125,000) but is seriously struggling. Obviously, the agent has no problem convincing folks he can sell their home. The problem lies in failing at some other very basic issues which are likely to prevent someone from converting a listing into a “closed” transaction. Let’s consider the most likely culprits.
Silly Details
This will surely not be stepping on your toes to mention “silly” reasons why a listing is unlikely to result in a sale.
- The owner filed bankruptcy, two weeks ago
- The spouse never signed the listing contract
- The lender will be “short” and no one mentioned it
- The house is already scheduled for a sheriff’s sale
- The paperwork for a deed-in-lieu was mailed the day you had your listing appointment
- The “summons” was received two (2) days before they called you
Shame on YOU
In today’s market it is not intrusive to conduct a thorough analysis of the reasons why a potential seller chooses to sell at this junction—that just reflects market savvy. Further, it is a disservice to the potential client and to your agency/yourself to list property without addressing the most common reasons why real estate becomes “unavailable” for the completion of the transaction in today’s market. What a shame to have unearthed the proverbial needle in a haystack (a qualified, ready and able buyer) only to discover you don’t have anything to sell. If you are lucky—really lucky—this qualified buyer will be too busy to sue your client for “failure to perform,” with yours truly as a co-conspirator.
Price ‘em RIGHT…from the beginning
The operative word is RIGHT. The correct view is from a buyer’s prospective. Must I tell you I mean for today’s market, not the market THAT WAS—which is no more. If you’re not able to convince a potential seller of the appropriate listing price based on your BPO/CMA and supporting documents, are you a good enough salesperson to convince someone to buy it at the inflated price you listed it for? Think about it.
Is the owner committed?
I’m sorry, I didn’t mean “should the owner be committed” or perhaps, “the owner plans to get committed.” I mean, IS THE OWNER, TODAY committed to selling their home? Well, how can you tell? That’s easy. An owner who is committed to selling has some basic awareness of the market and will be receptive to your education/documentation of current value. They will already be working on getting their home ready for showings and quite willing to set a definite date when those preparations will be complete. A committed seller is not “testing the water.” They have concrete plans for moving. In other words, they’re an active participant in their real estate process, not your reluctant sidekick.
Ready for the debut?
Not you, the house. Too often, in their anxiety to seal the deal and tally another listing, agents list homes which are not only not ready for showings (clutter, minor cosmetic issues which need to be addressed, lack of curb appeal, etc) but whose owner has demonstrated a lack of commitment to making them ready. It’s such a simple practice to ask “How long will it take to get your home ready for showings?” (Notice, I did not say for listing). Then clearly say, “Call me when it is ready for showings. We can then do the paperwork needed for the listing agreement and I will take photos for marketing.” There, wasn’t that simple? Don’t list a home you are ashamed to have viewed. Day One. Dot. Period.
The Four Rules for Listing
The “rules” I encourage you to implement assume your relationship with your client is strong enough to have resolved any issues related to:
- a. Appropriate market-based pricing
- b. Acceptable condition
- c. Provisions for showings
- d. Possible impact of “undisclosed pertinent information"
- e. Any “other” current realities
Rule #2—List at no more than 3-5% above the current market (short sale is an exception to this rule)
Rule #3—List only when the home is “camera ready”
Rule #4—List only AFTER the seller has demonstrated they are committed to selling
Closing = Commission Paid
Now for the first and most important rule. The FIRST rule for listing should be: Don’t list anything you don’t REALISTICALLY believe you can close. It was a good rule to live by when I started my real estate career in the early 90’s. This was not a company rule, but my personal standard in order to become a successful REALTOR®. My logic was that if I closed everything I listed, then folks would believe that I was a good REALTOR®. Such a novel idea. But it worked. My fall-thru rate with buyers was less than 5%, almost always because of inspections issues. My expired listings—less than 1%. Time on market—well below the average for the market then. I appreciate that times have changed. Nonetheless, it was an excellent idea then. I encourage you to consider adopting it as your personal mandate today. You’ll accept fewer listings, but if you close 90-95% of what you list, will you be better off in 2009 than you were in 2008? You do the assessment. It’s a business decision. Marketing listings which are not likely to sell is costly.
6% of Nothing is Nothing
One of the prime reasons I teach and write is because I recognized that the strategies which are being used by many agents are counterproductive and therefore, very frustrating. Handling foreclosed properties for Fannie Mae, after some well-meaning agent had tried to sell them—the traditional way—predictably resulting in foreclosure—I decided to teach agents how to better understand the lender/insurer’s position, and how to successfully structure a short sale. It works, IF YOU WORK IT.
Getting to the closing table is the ultimate goal for all real estate professionals. Strategies for posturing yourself, from the inception of the transaction, with the goal of getting to the closing is the cornerstone of the foreclosure related classes taught by HOM. The (FIS) certification is wholly focused on GETTING TO THE CLOSING TABLE.
Want to learn more?
Web: www.HomeOwnershipMatters.com.
Blog: http://www.HomeOnwershipMatters.blogspot.com/
Mildred Wilkins
President of Home Ownership Matters
Author of “Your Real Estate Advisor”
available at: www.DovePublishingHouse.com
Toll-free 1 (866) 507-5105
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
You can find more articles by Mildred at HOM's website.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
October 12, 2009
WORD: HUD-1 Settlement Statement
And the WORD for Today is...
HUD-1 Settlement Statement – is required under RESPA guidelines and is the form at closing which details all the expenses associated with the transfer of the property. ALL the costs of the deal are to be included for both the borrower and the lender’s sake. A borrower should receive a signed copy of the HUD-1 before they leave the closing.
The HUD-1 is a standard form that clearly shows all charges imposed on borrowers and sellers in connection with the settlement. RESPA allows the borrower to request to see the HUD-1 Settlement Statement one day before the actual settlement. The settlement agent must then provide the borrowers with a completed HUD-1 Settlement Statement based on information known to the agent at that time.
The HUD-1 Settlement Statement shows the actual settlement costs of the loan transaction. Separate forms may be prepared for the borrower and the seller. Where it is not the practice that the borrower and the seller both attend the settlement, the HUD-1 should be mailed or delivered as soon as practicable after settlement.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
You can find more helpful definitions of WORDS like these in Your Real Estate Advisor which can be purchased atwww.DovePublishingHouse.com.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
September 28, 2009
Q&A: Is the Seller Responsible for back taxes?
A: Short answer: YES, to both.
Individual sellers of real estate are required to provide a clear chain of title and that requires that any back taxes or tax liens would have to be satisfied prior to or at the closing. In order to demonstrate that there are no outstanding debts against the property, the seller signs a vendor’s affidavit which affirms that there are no outstanding obligations which have not been paid. Additionally, they provide the purchaser with a general warranty deed further guaranteeing that a clear title has been conveyed.
Buyer Beware—Bank-owned sellers
The use of the word ‘their’ in the question above indicates you are talking about buying a home from an individual rather than an REO (bank-owned property) from an insurer such as HUD, VA, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. While these insurers are required to pay back taxes and Federal tax liens before they transfer title, they are NOT required to cover all liens and consequently you will most often receive what is called a “special warranty deed”, “sheriff’s deed” or “trustee’s deed”. Irrespective of what it is called, any of these types of deeds will be transferring “marketable title” but not necessarily “clear title” to you. You owe it to yourself to get clarity on all the words highlighted in this section before you purchase a home which is being offered for sale by an institution rather than an individual.
Pass it on! your ‘contingency’ and move to a closing.
What are contingencies?
They are stumbling blocks which must be addressed before you can close on the new home purchase. It might be that you have a home you must sell first. It might be that you need to get money from a 401K and have not yet applied for that to be released. You might need to pay off some outstanding judgments in order to get final loan approval to complete this transaction. It could be that you are awaiting a final answer from your employer about a possible job transfer or any one (or ten) other things.
Most important is to discuss with your agent whether or not there are conditions in the content of your offer, (probably under further conditions) which grant the seller permission to continue to show the home. If there are NO contingencies then I would say the home should have been pended and no, there should be no further showings.
Real estate contracts are somewhat complex but you really can understand them if you take the time to understand what the words really mean. Read your specific contract and see what they can and cannot legally do until the closing actually occurs. Best of luck.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
September 7, 2009
WORD: Closing Protection Coverage
And the WORD for Today Is:
Closing Protection Coverage – is a well-kept secret which relates to a closing on a local real estate transaction. Unlike the title policy which pertains to the title of the property, closing protection coverage pertains to the handling of the funds and documents by the closing agent. Closing protection coverage covers losses due to the mishandling of funds or documents by the authorized closing agent. If a borrower chooses to purchase closing protection coverage, then they have coverage against loss of settlement funds resulting from any of the following acts of the licensed agent or anyone acting on behalf of the licensed agent, subject to restrictions or exclusions identified in the coverage:
- Theft fraud, misappropriation or any other failure to properly disburse settlement, closing or escrow funds;
- Failure to comply with any applicable written closing instructions, when agreed to by the licensed agent. (See closing agent).
You must be specifically named in the closing protection coverage form in order to be protected. A copy of this form is available to you, upon request.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
You can find more helpful definitions of WORDS like these in Your Real Estate Advisor which can be purchased at www.DovePublishingHouse.com.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
You can find more helpful definitions of WORDS like these in Your Real Estate Advisor which can be purchased at www.DovePublishingHouse.com.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
September 4, 2009
Short Sale Buyer: 10 Critical Areas of Concern
Short Sale BUYER
Ten (10) Critical Areas of Concern
If you are thinking of buying a home in today’s market, there is a pretty good chance that you will find a home you like which is upside down (seller owes more than the house is worth in today’s market and the sale will require that the lender approve a short sale). Buying a ‘short sale’ is not necessarily a BAD thing but it is definitely a DIFFERENT thing than a regular purchase and so you need to ask yourself some important questions before you embark on this journey. I am going to assume that if you know the right questions to ask that you will be diligent about getting some good answers before you move forward.
Here are areas where you need to do your homework:
- AGENT—Is your real estate agent experienced in working with short sale buyers? Know how short sale transactions differ from regular transactions? Provided you with sufficient documentation to help you know what the current value of the property is?
- TIMING—Are you aware that it could take months (several months) for you to get an answer and go to closing on a short sale? Can you afford to wait for an indefinite period of time? Can you STAY in your current housing until you get closed—however long that might be? Did you know you can decide to walk away anytime you want to even though you have made an offer? Simply tell your agent to rescind your offer if you want to consider another house. (You know to do that in writing, yes?)
- NEIGHBORHOOD—Have you done the research you need to do to be sure that the back side of the neighborhood is as appealing as the front side? Are you comfortable with the mix of owners vs. tenants in the neighborhood? Is the neighborhood moving more toward tenants? Are homes well-kept or more of them in disrepair? Have you driven the area at night—do you feel comfortable with the nighttime look and feel of the area you will be calling home? Is there a significant numbers of homes empty—whether for sale or otherwise available for occupancy (rent, lease, etc)? Are property values still falling or have they hit a plateau? Where did you check? (and don’t tell me you just asked your agent). Are you comfortable with the levels of taxes in the area? Are there any special assessments which you need to consider? If there is a neighborhood association, how financially sound is it? Have you stopped and talked to neighbors to see what is REALLY GOING ON IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD?
- PROCESS—Did your agent carefully explain the short sale process to you? Did you ask for a response based on how long you are willing to wait (2-3 months) or based on the traditional practice of allowing only a few days? You wrote an offer which was presented to the local owner/seller but then forwarded to their lender/servicer for consideration. Are you aware that the lender may/will consider multiple offers and then make a decision on ONE of them? Were you warned that the Lender may counter your offer—after a very long time—even months after you initially wrote the offer? Are you prepared to increase the amount you are willing to pay or risk losing the house? Have you pre-determined how much you are willing to pay? May I suggest that should be the amount you should offer in the first place?
- RISKS—Are numerous but forewarned is better than being caught off guard. Risks include:
a. The SELLER may file bankruptcy—and the house cannot be sold to anyone
b. The LENDER may foreclose and the property become unavailable
c. ANOTHER OFFER may be accepted instead of yours (even if the seller signs your offer that does not mean that the LENDER/SERVICER is going to approve your offer instead of another one which they have received) - LONGTERM—Have you carefully considered whether this house meets your long-term needs (say for the next 10 years)? Lifestyle? Location? Size? Amenities? Condition? Does it have ‘growth potential’?
- FINANCING—Do you already have a firm loan commitment from your institution—not a pre-approval? You should start out with a /loan commitment/ to increase your chances of getting your offer accepted and to avoid any surprises down the road. Can your lender use the appraisal recently acquired by the selling institution in order to speed up the process at the end? Did you know that your earnest money check should not be cashed until AFTER you have an offer accepted by the LENDER who is the real decision maker on a short sale transaction? (That could be 3 months from now.)
- INSPECTION—Are you aware that most states allow you to have inspections on any property which you wish to acquire (including REO’s, short sales and anything listed ”as is”?) Is your agent encouraging you to have a full property inspection as a way to be sure you fully understand the ACTUAL condition of the property you want to acquire? (Good agents will insist that you should, especially on a short sale which probably has not been well maintained if the home is in foreclosure). Are you aware that you can decide NOT to move ahead with the purchase if the inspection shows some substantial issues which are unacceptable to you?
- REPAIRS—Are you prepared to cover the cost for any repairs which are needed immediately (and in the near future) once you close? Have you gotten estimates based on the items uncovered during the inspection?
- GETTING TO THE CLOSING—Are you prepared to wait a few or several months to get to the closing date? Are you comfortable knowing you may be asked to increase your offer amount at the last minute, once the lender knows EXACTLY how much is needed to make the deal work under the guidelines from the Guarantor on the loan?
I am a firm believer that if you point someone in the right direction, they will usually get where they were headed. These are not ALL the questions you need to be asking but you are certainly headed in the right direction.
A short sale does not have to be a nightmare. Not with an experienced agent and a well educated consumer. Good luck with your new home experience.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
August 4, 2009
Q&A: Home Inspection—Worth Every $$$$
Q: We recently sold our home using a REALTOR, a septic tank test was not done. The REALTOR did not suggest we have the house inspected and it did not occur to us that we should do so. Who should have had made the arrangements for the septic test and made sure everything was up to code?
A: Your question is an excellent one and points out the need for a pre-inspection to be completed by you, the seller, BEFORE you list your home. I have to lay responsibility for this one at your agent’s feet. Yes, it is your house and you are responsible for maintaining it but the biggest part of what you pay a real estate commission for is ‘sound recommendations from a professional whose training should have prepared them’ to tell you what I am about to tell you.
Your question was: Who should have made the arrangements for the test? It is unimportant who made the call, you or your agent, to a septic company to come out and do the inspection. Either your agent could have handled that on your behalf or made several recommendations so that you had picked up the phone and actually called someone.
The missing piece seems to be that there was no discussion about the NEED for such an inspection at the appropriate time. Pre-inspections save sellers a lot of heartburn and usually a lot of money as well.
In the industry, agents are pretty divided and very vocal about whether or not it is in the best interests of a seller to spend the money for an inspection which would have uncovered this problem (as well as any other major problems). I am adamant that a pre-inspection should be conducted on any property which is more than a few years old because of the strong possibility that problems exist which can best be taken care of BEFORE the listing has occurred.
Opponents of pre-inspections insist:
Additionally, there was a crack in the interior chimney wall. This was a lovely $350,000 home and the sellers could have and should have corrected those items before it was listed. The problems were, in fact, fixable. The sellers initially offered some half-baked resolution, which we rejected.
My clients were prepared to walk away and even leave their $3,000 earnest money on the table. They just didn’t want the house any more. A house they had loved and had picked as their retirement home. I prepared a very precise inspection response—quite frankly asking for more than they had to do and they refused. We requested and received a mutual release. We had to fuss a little bit, but their earnest money was returned.
The sellers of the home had already started construction on their new dream home, had had this house on the market for more than six months and now they had to start all over trying to find a new buyer. Plus, they still had to fix everything they should have fixed before. All for lack of a pre-inspection.
During my career as a REALTOR I helped many clients terminate the contract (and get their money back) as the result of significant inspection issues we could not come to terms over.
Much of the time we walked away from the transaction if the seller was not willing to give us EXACTLY what we wanted in the way of a fix. It is definitely not a position of strength for the seller to discover they have any major issue in the time leading up to a possible closing.
After helping numerous buyers ‘walk’ because we were not satisfied with the compromise of repair or other concessions from the seller, I eventually established a personal policy of refusing to list a home unless the seller agreed to a pre-inspection with one of the toughest inspection companies in the city and further agreed to repair the offending items before we listed.
Like I said, I have to drop this at the feet of the REALTOR for failure to adequately prepare you for just such a situation as later occurred. Additionally, I would be interested in whether or not the septic system is specifically addressed on a Seller’s disclosure form, if your state uses one. Any agent worth their salt would have checked to be sure you understood all the questions you were being asked on such a form.
The issue of pre-inspections gets my adrenaline flowing. I should probably go have a glass of tea.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
A: Your question is an excellent one and points out the need for a pre-inspection to be completed by you, the seller, BEFORE you list your home. I have to lay responsibility for this one at your agent’s feet. Yes, it is your house and you are responsible for maintaining it but the biggest part of what you pay a real estate commission for is ‘sound recommendations from a professional whose training should have prepared them’ to tell you what I am about to tell you.
Your question was: Who should have made the arrangements for the test? It is unimportant who made the call, you or your agent, to a septic company to come out and do the inspection. Either your agent could have handled that on your behalf or made several recommendations so that you had picked up the phone and actually called someone.
The missing piece seems to be that there was no discussion about the NEED for such an inspection at the appropriate time. Pre-inspections save sellers a lot of heartburn and usually a lot of money as well.
In the industry, agents are pretty divided and very vocal about whether or not it is in the best interests of a seller to spend the money for an inspection which would have uncovered this problem (as well as any other major problems). I am adamant that a pre-inspection should be conducted on any property which is more than a few years old because of the strong possibility that problems exist which can best be taken care of BEFORE the listing has occurred.
Opponents of pre-inspections insist:
- That the seller should not waste money on an inspection when the buyer is going to have one anyway
- That the seller is unnecessarily spending $300-$400 which they could make better use of by putting in some flowers
- Believe that you would avoid uncovering something which could be a deal breaker AFTER you have an accepted offer (don’t you hate when that happens?)
- That the cost is a wise investment in the success of your real estate transaction
- That if you uncover any significant problems you are in a better position to search out the right professionals to correct them and price shop for the best value as well as schedule that work at your convenience rather than be in a rush to get it done
- That if the needed repairs represent a significant investment, then you can adjust what you’re considering listing the house for rather than have an unexpected expense eat into your profits at the end
- That an investment for the “extra” inspections (mold, termite and septic system) of $200-$300 above the base cost could save you thousands of dollars at the back end since you can’t renegotiate the sales price AFTER the buyer hits you with repairs which are mandated as allowable under your state’s SELLER DISCLOSURE law. A septic repair/replacement would definitely be covered in most states and a repair could cost upwards of $1,000. The replacement of the septic system or an expansion of the field or the finger system could set you back MANY thousands of dollars. Likewise, a possible termite problem should keep you awake at night, UNLESS you had a pre-inspection and know that you don’t have any.
Additionally, there was a crack in the interior chimney wall. This was a lovely $350,000 home and the sellers could have and should have corrected those items before it was listed. The problems were, in fact, fixable. The sellers initially offered some half-baked resolution, which we rejected.
My clients were prepared to walk away and even leave their $3,000 earnest money on the table. They just didn’t want the house any more. A house they had loved and had picked as their retirement home. I prepared a very precise inspection response—quite frankly asking for more than they had to do and they refused. We requested and received a mutual release. We had to fuss a little bit, but their earnest money was returned.
The sellers of the home had already started construction on their new dream home, had had this house on the market for more than six months and now they had to start all over trying to find a new buyer. Plus, they still had to fix everything they should have fixed before. All for lack of a pre-inspection.
During my career as a REALTOR I helped many clients terminate the contract (and get their money back) as the result of significant inspection issues we could not come to terms over.
Much of the time we walked away from the transaction if the seller was not willing to give us EXACTLY what we wanted in the way of a fix. It is definitely not a position of strength for the seller to discover they have any major issue in the time leading up to a possible closing.
After helping numerous buyers ‘walk’ because we were not satisfied with the compromise of repair or other concessions from the seller, I eventually established a personal policy of refusing to list a home unless the seller agreed to a pre-inspection with one of the toughest inspection companies in the city and further agreed to repair the offending items before we listed.
Like I said, I have to drop this at the feet of the REALTOR for failure to adequately prepare you for just such a situation as later occurred. Additionally, I would be interested in whether or not the septic system is specifically addressed on a Seller’s disclosure form, if your state uses one. Any agent worth their salt would have checked to be sure you understood all the questions you were being asked on such a form.
The issue of pre-inspections gets my adrenaline flowing. I should probably go have a glass of tea.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
July 9, 2009
Your Real Estate Advisor: 4 Prudent Rules for Buyers of Short Sale Listings
Four Prudent Rules for BUYERS Who Write Offers on Short Sale Listings
Rule 1: STAY PUT: Do not give notice in your existing housing until after you have closed on a short sale listing. Even if you have to pay a significant amount to go to a month to month arrangement where you currently live. The path to a closing on a short sale listing could get bumpy. The seller might:
- File for bankruptcy which removes the home from availability
- Receive an offer from another potential purchaser which the lender decides to accept instead of your offer
- Lose the home to foreclosure in which case you will no longer have a valid offer and will need to attempt to purchase it as an REO, if you are still interested
You should not be celebrating that you are going to be closing if the seller signed but you do not have the lender’s approval. Lenders make the final decisions on short sales, not the sellers who are upside down nor the REALTORS who are unfamiliar with or unwilling to bend to the way short sale transactions are typically handled.
Rule 3: BE PATIENT: We mean be prepared to be ‘seriously’ patient, like for a few months. Literally. Buying a home which is listed for a short sale can get you a great deal on a property, but you must be prepared to wait for an extended period of time (2-3 months is common). The lender has numerous things they must check and cross-check before they can approve a short sale. Watch for a future blog on “What is Taking Them So Long?” We’ll address the laundry list of things which must be checked before a short sale can be approved.
Rule 4: EXPECT A COUNTER: Four things you should understand from the beginning:
- Your offer is likely to be set aside until the lender gathers the information they need to make a decision
- Your offer is likely to be ‘joined’ by additional offers during this waiting period
- The Lender is likely to present a COUNTER OFFER to the potential purchaser who they believe has the offer which will net them the most
- That this COUNTER may not be presented to all potential buyers
It’s all in the game. All in the wonderful game that we know as: Short Sale.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
June 26, 2009
Q&A: Pended House—Available?
Q: My wife found this house which we really, really love from looking at the outside and peeping in the windows. When we called our agent to tell her we wanted to look at it she told us ‘It is pended’. If a sale is pending on a house, can I still take a walk-through with my agent and if I want it, make an offer?
A: Yes and Maybe. Real estate is changing at break neck speed these days and things which were iron clad just a few months ago are not so concrete any more. Coupled with the fact that all real estate agents do not understand exactly what certain terms mean, causing them to misuse terms and confuse the general public as well as other agents.
“Pended” is SUPPOSED to mean that there is an accepted offer between a bona-fide buyer and a seller. It is SUPPOSED to mean that the parties have agreed on all terms and are waiting for a closing date in the near future. However, it does not always mean that in today’s market. Today there are agents who “pend” properties which have been listed as potential short sales once they have an “offer in hand”. Such an offer must always be accepted not only by the homeowner who is upside down and possibly in default, but also by the lender who will be ‘shorted’ at a potential closing. When this is the case, an offer being submitted does not equate to an acceptance by the lender. Additionally, the fact that the homeowner who is attempting to sell has agreed, does not necessarily mean that the lender will go along with that specific offer.
Under the scenario I just described, it is possible to have an offer ‘pended’ in your local mls which has not been lender approved and which could be viewed, followed by an offer being written which the lender could entertain. On short sales, the lender reserves the right to consider all offers until THE LENDER has granted approval and ordered a closing. They reserve that right up until the time of the actual closing
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
A: Yes and Maybe. Real estate is changing at break neck speed these days and things which were iron clad just a few months ago are not so concrete any more. Coupled with the fact that all real estate agents do not understand exactly what certain terms mean, causing them to misuse terms and confuse the general public as well as other agents.
“Pended” is SUPPOSED to mean that there is an accepted offer between a bona-fide buyer and a seller. It is SUPPOSED to mean that the parties have agreed on all terms and are waiting for a closing date in the near future. However, it does not always mean that in today’s market. Today there are agents who “pend” properties which have been listed as potential short sales once they have an “offer in hand”. Such an offer must always be accepted not only by the homeowner who is upside down and possibly in default, but also by the lender who will be ‘shorted’ at a potential closing. When this is the case, an offer being submitted does not equate to an acceptance by the lender. Additionally, the fact that the homeowner who is attempting to sell has agreed, does not necessarily mean that the lender will go along with that specific offer.
Under the scenario I just described, it is possible to have an offer ‘pended’ in your local mls which has not been lender approved and which could be viewed, followed by an offer being written which the lender could entertain. On short sales, the lender reserves the right to consider all offers until THE LENDER has granted approval and ordered a closing. They reserve that right up until the time of the actual closing
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
June 11, 2009
Q&A: Bankruptcy "Stay" and Short Sale Listing
Q: We have not been able to keep up our mortgage payments and finally decided to list the house for short sale so maybe we can save our credit by not having a foreclosure on our record. Nobody seems to be buying houses in our area and several folks have said we just need to go ahead and file bankruptcy but keep the house out of it. Is this possible? We don’t want to make a mistake while trying to resolve this issue.
A: You can’t file bankruptcy and ‘keep the house out of it’. The house is an asset and the Trustee of the court will ultimately decide what will be done with any and all assets. The closing of a short sale can not be completed while a home is still in bankruptcy. Only after the Trustee has made a decision to allow removal of the home from the petition and allow it to be placed (or put back) on the market should this be done.
If a borrower has a home listed for a potential short sale and then files for bankruptcy protection an “automatic stay” goes into effect as soon as the bankruptcy is filed. The “stay” means several things. Including;
- All creditors are prohibited from calling or harassing the borrower until there is a disposition of the bankruptcy
- All assets are “frozen” until the court has made a decision about what is to be done with them
- All loss mitigation discussions must cease until the bankruptcy is completed (that includes a possible short sale)
Deed-in-lieu dilemma
For the reason just discussed, a person who believes they might be able to complete a short sale would be ill-advised to file for bankruptcy protection since it blocks this option. Additionally, since the Trustee of the Bankruptcy court might order a deed-in-lieu (forcing the person to relinquish the house) you should make this your last, last option.
You relinquish any control of the situation by filing bankruptcy. Additionally, there is the possibility that if you are required to sign a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure that you might later be faced with a deficiency judgment which you might have negotiated away if you had worked directly with the lender to complete the short sale.
I would encourage you to work aggressively with your real estate agent and your lender to try to get the short sale approved. In the meantime, stay in your home, no matter how far behind you are in the mortgage payments.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
May 24, 2009
FYI: Short Sale–Slow Crawl
What they DIDN’T tell you about short sale offers
The man back at the bank has a few things to take care of before he can respond to the offer you just made to buy a home as a short sale. Did your REALTOR mention?
The Lender must:
- Order an appraisal (could take awhile)
- Order title work (won’t take long but has it been ordered)
- Get a broker price opinion completed (hopefully the real estate agent knows what they are doing)
- Check to be sure there are no unpaid homeowner’s association dues or municipal bills which must be paid (could add to what YOU have to pay)
- Check to be sure that the SELLER qualifies for a short sale under the guidelines for the specific insurer for this property—at this time—since those guidelines are changing pretty rapidly lately
- Check all the details of the SELLER’s financials to be sure they have no assets or other reasons why a short sale cannot be approved (did they even send this stuff in yet)
- Verify that there are no Federal liens which must be satisfied
- Work out a deal with the SELLER’s second lien holder, if there is one
- Check with the insurer on the home to be sure that the guidelines for accepting a short sale are being followed
- Consider ANY/ALL offers which have been submitted on this home to be sure they respond to the one which will net the lender the most, after expenses (You did know they could consider other offers, right?)
- Negotiate with the SELLER what will be done about the shortage (on certain loan types)
- Review a preliminary HUD statement to be sure that the numbers which were provided by the LISTING agent on a net sheet are going to allow the lender to new what is required by their insurer or investor to close
- Present a Counter Offer, to the buyer with the BEST, overall offer, if the preliminary HUD reflects that the net will be below the acceptable amount required
- Must not allow a closing which not protect the interest of the insurer/investor
Somebody told you all this, right? If not, maybe your agent doesn’t understand short sales as well as they need to. Sure glad you found the information on this blog. Just a word of caution: don’t sign a notice to vacate your current residence until AFTER you get a signed approval letter from the lender granting permission for a short sale. This could take a little while.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
May 19, 2009
Q&A: Promised Perks
Q. I am not quite sure whether or not I have a legal problem but I think I got shafted and I want to know what to do about it. I recently bought a new house and the real estate agent promised me a cash rebate as well as a bonus from the builder if I purchased. I was supposed to receive these as soon as I closed. The rebate and bonus were not mentioned at the closing and now the agent refuses to talk to me. What should I do and how do I get the money I was promised?
A: Well, let’s see. You were promised a cash rebate and a bonus which appear to be outside the scope of the “official” or legal transaction since you did not receive the money as part of the closing on the home you purchased.
I am very carefully saying here that the promises made to you do not appear to be legal. Kickbacks seldom are. Trying to enforce an illegal promise could get a little dicey.
When you purchase a home (including new construction) the purpose of the lender’s appraisal is to be sure that:
a. The home is at least worth what they are about to loan you to acquire it.
b. That no amount in excess of the value of the home is being financed
For example, that you are not financing a house worth only $400,000 with a loan of, say $425,000 to allow enough money left from the lender’s funds to give you a kickback of $15,000 and a bonus of $10,000 (for furniture or a vacation or anything remotely like that). That is commonly called mortgage fraud.
The title company has a responsibility to be sure that there are no components of the closing which are in violation of the law. The title company can not be responsible for what the parties agreed to if it is not in the contract and not part of the closing instructions sent over from the lender. One of the requirements for a legal closing is that there be no “undisclosed” exchange of funds, such as kickbacks from the seller to entice you to buy.
All funds which are to exchange hands between any of the parties associated with the transaction are to be included on the HUD-1 document. It is against the law in most places for someone to pay you a rebate and a bonus to get you to buy the home they built. (I know the car companies did it, but look at them now. Apparently their guidelines are a bit more lax than real estate transactions and look at where it got them.)
The HUD-1 is the official record of the transaction and anything which cannot appear on it usually is suspect. In fact, fairly often during the last several years, what is on the HUD-1 frequently could stand a little more scrutiny.
I’m a grown-up so I know that what you described was not uncommon practice during the past 4-5 years in some of the hottest markets in the country. Wild construction growth, wild deals, wild foreclosures now. I am familiar with parking lot exchanges and promissory notes and gifts, rebates and bonuses which cannot appear on the HUD. Property values are falling in markets like California and Florida where I live like parachutes, in part, because one of the components of speculative building was to build in ‘extras’ such as the two things you asked about. The country is experiencing both a market correction to more realistic value for homes but also a major part of the problem was that the loans covered more than the piece of real estate, if you get my drift.
What should you do? Enjoy your new home and try to keep up the payments. You got took!
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
May 16, 2009
WORD: Listing Agent
And the WORD for Today is:
Listing Agent—is the real estate agent who obtains a listing to sell a property as apposed to the selling agent who brings the purchase agreement/buyer to consummate the closing.
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
You can find more helpful definitions of WORDS like these in Your Real Estate Advisor which can be purchased at www.DovePublishingHouse.com.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
May 13, 2009
Q&A: Earnest Money
Q. I recently encountered a problem while trying to purchase a house and I am not sure how to proceed at this point. I did not CHANGE my mind about the purchase; instead my bank refused to make the loan at the last minute after providing me with a pre-approval earlier. Now the seller is refusing to release my earnest money deposit of $2,500. I cannot afford to walk away from that much money. Can he legally do this? What are my next steps in trying to get my money back?
A: The release of a deposit from escrow can be a little dicey, but let’s talk about it. Your question specifically asks whether it is legal for the seller to refuse to release your earnest money deposit.
Technically, when money is held in escrow the holder of the escrow (Broker of the Listing firm, an attorney who is managing the escrow account or occasionally a title company) is who would release the money. They are prohibited from doing so until either:
- There is a closing and the funds are distributed as part of the closing
- There is a mutual release signed by both the buyer and the seller agreeing to all conditions of the release, or
- A court which has jurisdiction over this matter determines who is entitled to funds
Ordinarily, a purchase agreement would have outlined the terms and conditions under which you would be entitled to receive your deposit. Most often, if you are denied financing, you would be allowed to receive the deposit in full from the escrow company. However, in order to be sure that both parties are in agreement and that no one is going to sue anyone else about the release of the money, both buyer and seller would need to sign a mutual release. Usually this is a one page document which basically says, things didn’t work out for whatever the specific reason happens to be and everyone agrees to go home and nobody’s going to sue anybody. The release also allows for negotiating how the earnest money will be split. It may be:
- Returned to the buyer (for some reason beyond their control, like lack of funding)
- Retained by the seller as liquidated damages (because you caused them some expense)
- Shared in some manner (say 50% to buyer and 50% to seller)
I would recommend that you approach (or that your agent approach) the listing Broker to discuss the merits of your request to have the funds returned to you. Be prepared to demonstrate the failure to get funding by providing a letter from your lender which states as much. Remain civil and approach them in the spirit of goodwill. If you believe that it would be fair to do so, then compromise and offer to split the earnest money as I suggested above sometimes happens.
As a last resort, consider the possibility of filing a claim in small claims court where you would be allowed to present your evidence as to why you should receive the funds back. In that case, the judge would decide who gets the money.
If it is any comfort to you, neither you nor the seller can get it until there is either a mutual release or a court disposition. Something’s gotta give!
Copyright © 2008, Home Ownership Matters, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Please E-mail Heather at homeownershipmatters@gmail.com with any questions, comments or concerns you might have! We appreciate all comments and feedback, so please don't be shy.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
